Tartan is 29, single, and Mormon. Tired of being set up by his marriage-conscious mother, Tartan takes a job as a forest ranger in Longfellow, a sleepy town where half the population is Mormon, the other half is Baptist, and nobody can get along. While Tartan's arrival rekindles the longtime feud between Mormons and Baptists, the arrival of the beautiful Charity rekindles Tartan's desire to tie the knot. Together they plot to hold an all-faiths barbecue, but it's met with some resistance from both sides of the pew. Will Tartan's efforts bring the town together? And can Tartan convince Charity to stay in town?